WhiteHat Sentinel PE security penetration testing
BMC Remedy ITSM 9.0 and BMC Remedy AR System 9.0 use the WhiteHat Sentinel Premium Edition (WhiteHat Sentinel PE) service, a dynamic application security tool (DAST), for security penetration testing. By performing security penetration testing, BMC can identify whether applications are vulnerable to web attacks and implement the required countermeasures to reduce vulnerabilities.
As of April 6, 2015, BMC Remedy ITSM 9.0 and BMC Remedy AR System 9.0 do not have any security penetration vulnerabilities.
This topic contains the following information:
For BMC Remedy ITSM 9.0 and BMC Remedy AR System 9.0, BMC schedules automated security scans with WhiteHat Security that are run on the SaaS-based WhiteHat Sentinel platform. Automated scans are augmented by manual penetration tests performed by WhiteHat security experts. After the tests are completed, BMC receives vulnerability assessment reports. For more information about WhiteHat Sentinel, see https://www.whitehatsec.com/sentinel_services/benefits.html.
For BMC Remedy ITSM 9.0 and BMC Remedy AR System 9.0, security penetration tests were performed using a BMC Remedy OnDemand instance deployed in the following environment:
WhiteHat security vulnerability tests
As of April 6, 2015, WhiteHat Security has run 242 automated security scans of BMC Remedy AR System 9.0 and BMC Remedy ITSM 9.0. Whitehat Security performs manual testing by further exploring areas found during the automated testing.
WhiteHat Security employs the following types of tests during the security testing:
- Authentication tests (brute force, insufficient authentication, weak password recovery, cross-site request forgery, credential/session prediction, insufficient authorization, insufficient session expiration, session fixation)
- Client-side attack tests (content spoofing, cross-site scripting, HTTP response splitting)
- Command execution tests (buffer overflow, format string attack, LDAP injection, OS commanding, SQL injection, server-side include injection, XPath injection)
- Information disclosure tests (directory indexing, information leakage, path traversal, predictable resource location)
- Logical attack tests (abuse of functionality, denial of service, insufficient anti-automation, insufficient process validation)
For more information about WhiteHat Security, see the website security statement for WhiteHat Security.
Whitehat PCI Compliance Testing
Whitehat also test for compliance with the Payment Card Industry Data Security Standard (PCI-DSS Version 3.0), which includes requirements that web applications be built to secure coding guidelines and that applications be subject to routine vulnerability checks. The following categories of PCI tests are employed:
- Injection flaws
- Buffer overflow
- Insecure Cryptographic Storage
- Insecure Communications
- Improper Error Handling
- Cross Site Scripting
- Improper Access Control
- Cross Site Request Forgery
- Broken Authentication and Session Management
For more information about the WhiteHat Sentinel PE tests that were used and the results, which are zero technical and business logic vulnerabilities, see the following reports:
BMC and Whitehat Security are continually running tests as BMC augments the environment or adds new security tests.
|Component||Server specifications||VM used?||Operating system|
|BMC Remedy Mid Tier 9.0||Yes||CentOS release 6.5 (Final)|
BMC Atrium Single Sign-on 8.8.00.01.05
BMC Remedy AR System 9.0
BMC Remedy ITSM 9.0
|Yes||Microsoft Windows Server 2008 R2 (64-bit)|
BMC Remedy Smart Reporting
CentOS release 6.2 (Final)
Refer to BMC Atrium Single Sign-on security settings for a complete list of security settings used in this environment.
Changes required for on-premise and BMC Remedy OnDemand environments
The following changes are required for on-premise and BMC Remedy OnDemand environments to achieve zero technical and business logic vulnerabilities in BMC Remedy 9.0 and BMC Remedy AR System 9.0:
Configuring Apache Tomcat settings to disable directory listings
To prevent a security vulnerability from directory listings, BMC used the following procedure to disable directory listings on the Tomcat web server hosting BMC Remedy Mid Tier:
- Stop the Tomcat server.
- Use a text editor to edit the <CATALINA_HOME>\conf\web.xml file.
- Change the param-value for the listings parameter to false.
- Save the change.
- Restart the Tomcat server.
When you disable the directory listings, you will also disable online help. To enable online help:
- Install a separate Tomcat instance on a different port on the BMC Remedy Mid Tier computer.
- Install online help in the Tomcat container in the Root folder of the Tomcat instance.
- Log on to BMC Remedy Mid Tier as an administrator and open the SHARE:Application_Properties Form.
- Search for Property Name = Help File Path.
Update the Property Value for all search result entries to point to the new online Help URL with the correct port number.
If you are using a reverse proxy (load balancer), further changes may be required to allow access to the new online help URL.
Creating an SSL profile on the reverse proxy to disable RC4 ciphers
RC4 ciphers are vulnerable to web attacks. The following procedure is an example of how BMC modified the default cipher support of the reverse proxy (load balancer) to disable Secure Sockets Layer (SSL) version 3 and RC4 ciphers:
The following procedure is specific to how BMC Remedy OnDemand uses SSL. An on-premise installation requires changes to the Apache Tomcat configuration to disable the RC4 ciphers.
- Log on to the Configuration utility for the reverse proxy (load balancer).
- Click Local Traffic.
- Click Profiles.
- From the SSL menu, select Client.
- Click Create.
- Type a name for the SSL profile.
- From the Parent Profile menu, select clientssl.
- From the Configuration menu, select Advanced.
- Click the Custom box for Ciphers.
- In the Ciphers box, enter the following string:
- Click Finished.
- Associate the SSL profile with the virtual server.
Restricting attachments by using Attachment Security
BMC used the Attachment Security feature provided with BMC Remedy AR System 8.1 SP1. This feature helps to prevent users from uploading malicious attachments and viewing them in the BMC Remedy Mid Tier. BMC defined the following attachment extensions as the only attachment extensions allowed for attachment uploads:
To restrict attachments, BMC used the following procedure to make the changes to the Attachment Security tab of the AR System Administration: Server Information form:
- Select the following options:
- Allow attachments with following extensions option in the Attachment criteria field
- Allow display of attachments with the following extensions option in the Display criteria field
- Define the list of attachment extensions (.txt, .png, .jpg) in the Comma separated list of limit extensions and Comma separated list of display extensions fields.
- Click Apply.
For additional information about how to restrict attachments, see.
The following image shows the changes made to the Attachment Security tab.
AR System Administration: Server Information form — Attachment Security tab
Enabling Login Failure Lockout in BMC Atrium SSO
With the Atrium SSO Login Failure Lockout procedure, an account can be locked after a number of failed login attempts. The number of failed attempts that triggers the lockout and the duration of the lockout are both configurable. For the BMC WhiteHat security testing, Login Failure Lockout was configured to lock the account for 15 minutes after three unsuccessful login attempts.
Use the Atrium SSO Realm Editor to configure Login Failure Lockout. For instructions on configuring the Realm Editor including Login Failure Lockout, refer to the BMC Atrium SSO Realm Editor topic.
Enabling Valid Forwarding Domains in BMC Atrium SSO
The Valid Forwarding Domains feature provides a limit to the domains that the BMC Atrium Single Sign-On server will forward to the browser after authentication. To enable this feature, you must provide at least one URL to the list of Valid Forwarding Domains. An empty list indicates that the feature is disabled.
To add a URL to the list of valid forwarding domains
- Insert the URL in the Trusted Domain field.
- Click Add.
- For the changes to take effect, restart the BMC Atrium Single Sign-on server.
Ensure that you provide the absolute path for the URL that you enter in the list of Valid Forwarding Domains, such as:
If you try to access a URL that is not present in Valid Forwarding Domains, you are redirected to a page that has an error message and a link to log out of the BMC Atrium Single Sign-On server.
The following Valid Forwarding Domains settings were used in the Whitehat security testing:
Enforcing the default password policy in BMC Remedy AR System
BMC Remedy AR System uses an MD5 hash of passwords stored in the database, ensuring that passwords cannot be retrieved. To enable and configure a password policy, refer to the topic Enforcing a password policy introduction. For the BMC WhiteHat security testing, the default password policy was enabled.
Securing BMC Atrium Single Sign-On as a stand-alone server
- Open the Edit Server Configuration tab on the BMC Atrium SSO Admin Console.
- Select the HTTP Only and HTTPS Only check boxes, and click Save.
- Restart the BMC Atrium Single Sign-On server.
- Clear all cookies from the browser history.
For more information, refer to Server Configuration Editor
F5 Load Balancer hotfix
In certain F5 Load Balancers, an active attacker may be able to recover plain text, such as authentication cookies, from a TLS1.x connection. The solution is to upgrade the F5 Local Traffic Manager (LTM) to the version 11.6 hotfix. Refer to the F5 support document https://support.f5.com/kb/en-us/solutions/public/15000/800/sol15882.html for additional information.
BMC Remedy Mid Tier security settings
The following table lists the BMC Remedy Mid Tier settings used for Whitehat security testing:
|Use Post for Backchannel calls|
Added following parameter in midtier/WEB-INF/classes/config.properties
|Plugin XSS Security Check|
Added following parameter in midtier/WEB-INF/classes/config.properties:
Turn on SecureCookieFilter
Uncommented following from midtier/WEB-INF/web.xml:
<filter> <filter-name>SecureCookieFilter</filter-name> <filterclass>com.remedy.arsys.stubs.SecureCookieFilter</fliter-class> </filter> <filter-mapping> <filter-name>SecureCookieFilter</filter-name> <url-pattern>/*</url-pattern> </filter-mapping>
Turn on XSSFilter
Uncommented following from midtier/WEB-INF/web.xml:
<filter> <filter-name>XSSFILTER</filter-name> <filter-class>com.remedy.arsys.stubs.XSSFilter</filter-class> </filter> <filter-mapping> <filter-name>XSSFILTER</filter-name> <url-pattern>/plugins/*</url-pattern> </filter-mapping> <filter-mapping> <filter-name>XSSFILTER</filter-name> <url-pattern>/pluginsignal/*</url-pattern> </filter-mapping>
Turn on CLICKJACKFILTER
Uncommented following from midtier/WEB-INF/web.xml:
<filter> <filter-name>CLICKJACKFILTER</filter-name> <filter-class>com.remedy.arsys.support.ClickJackFilter</filter-class> <init-param> <param-name>mode</param-name> <param-value>SAMEORIGIN</param-value> </init-param> </filter>
<filter-mapping> <filter-name>CLICKJACKFILTER</filter-name> <url-pattern>/*</url-pattern> </filter-mapping>